In ’91, fans displayed their idiocy by voting Alomar the starting catcher for the American League. Though he had won the Rookie of the Year award the season before, Alomar missed most of the first half with a rotator-cuff injury, and when he did play, he stunk. Alomar batted .241, and as his terrifyingly weak .305 slugging percentage demonstrates, he couldn’t really slug. For his part, Alomar pleaded not guilty to this heinous offense. “If you look at the stats, I know I shouldn’t be there,” Alomar said. “I don’t know why the people voted for me.” Neither do we.