Bayern Munich vs. Barcelona and Borussia Dortmund vs. Real Madrid: A Preview of the Champions League Semi-Finals

It doesn't get much better than this

  • Share
  • Read Later
Denis Balibouse / Reuters

A screen shows the results of the draw for the Champions League semi-finals matches at the UEFA headquarters in Nyon, April 12, 2013.

There was a joke doing the rounds on Twitter yesterday, in anticipation of Friday morning’s Champions League semi-final draw. The remaining four sides come from Spain and Germany – Barcelona, Real Madrid, Bayern Munich and Borussia Dortmund – and the first part of the gag was that if the teams from the same country were drawn against each other, it might be seen as a fix by soccer fans. The payoff? If the teams were kept apart, it would still be viewed as a fix. It was hardly Abbott and Costello doing “Who’s on first?” but it may have made you smile (accusations have been made over the years that soccer draws have been fixed.)

As it turned out, the German and Spanish sides were kept apart from each other with Bayern Munich at home in the first leg to Barcelona on Apr. 23 and Borussia Dortmund taking on Real Madrid the following night (the return legs are on Apr. 30 and May 1 with Madrid vs. Dortmund being played on the 30th). If the Spanish giants, who both play their second legs at home, which could be seen as an advantage, make it through, then “El Clasico,” the name by which their games are known, will take place at London’s Wembley Stadium in the May 25 final. Let’s take a look at the mouth-watering match ups.

(MORE: Why Barcelona vs. Real Madrid Is More Than a Game)

Bayern Munich vs. Barcelona

The immediate subplot that comes to mind is how arguably the most interested observer of them all will be a certain Pep Guardiola. The former Barcelona manager, who won 14 trophies over four years for Barca, is taking over as Bayern boss next season, and has been on a year-long sabbatical in New York. Whether he attends these games isn’t yet known but he, in addition to soccer fans around the world, will know that Barca’s number 10, Lionel Messi, will be the key to this semi-final. Barcelona made heavy weather of their quarter-final against Paris Saint-Germain, and required a not fully fit Messi to come off the bench and help rescue them during this week’s second leg (he sustained a hamstring injury in the first game). Messi was summoned after PSG took a shock lead, which would have been good enough to see the Parisian side through. While Messi didn’t score Barcelona’s equalizer, he played a major part in the build up to the goal, and it will be interesting to see if current coach, Tito Vilanova, will rest him over the next few weeks, with Barcelona all but assured the league title in Spain. “They gained in confidence as soon as he came on,” said PSG coach, Carlo Ancelotti. “He is the best player in the world, even if he is not fully fit.”

But Bayern’s own record against Barca is respectable, having won three, drawn two and only lost one (that said, Barcelona have never lost a European Cup knockout tie against German opposition, winning seven previous ties). Bayern, who are last year’s losing finalists, have dominated the German league, securing their 23rd title last weekend, and have looked pretty convincing in their attempt to go one step further than last season (switch out the reigning champions, Chelsea, for Dortmund, and this year’s semi-final line up is the same as last season). Bayern dismantled Juventus in the quarter-final, winning both games 2-0, and with players of the calibre of Arjen Robben, Mario Mandzukic and Bastian Schweinsteiger, they cannot be underestimated. And yet it’s entirely possible that even with their defensive frailties – the Catalan side hasn’t kept a clean sheet in the last 13 “Clasicos” – Barcelona could progress if Messi is on the field for the majority of the 180 minutes (or possibly 210, if it goes to extra time). The man who seems to have a lock on the best player of the year award can orchestrate play, both by scoring goals and making them for his teammates, which means that the “Clasico” final could be on the cards.

Prediction: First leg Bayern Munich 1- 1 Barcelona. Second leg Barcelona 2-0 Bayern Munich. Barcelona to go through 3-1 on aggregate (this is based on Messi playing the majority of both matches).

(MORE: Lionel Messi Is Player of the Year for the Fourth Time)

Borussia Dortmund vs. Real Madrid

Borussia Dortmund are the only unbeaten side left in the competition, which means that they should be taken seriously. Their charismatic coach, Jürgen Klopp, has instilled a never-say-die, gung-ho attitude in his young side, most recently proven by their stunning injury-time comeback to score twice and knock out Spanish side Malaga in dramatic circumstances (it was the first time a team needing to score two injury-time goals to win in the Champions League had done so since Manchester United in the 1999 final). They’ve only beaten Real Madrid once (losing twice, with three ties) but that 2-1 victory came in the group stages last October and they managed a credible 2-2 tie in the Bernabeu a couple of weeks later. Polish striker Robert Lewandowski is a constant threat, with Mario Götze and Marco Reus offering much promise. But their 12th man is, to put it mildly, their passionate home crowd, who will surely never give up hope.

But will passion be enough to get past one of the world’s best coaches, Jose Mourinho, who, in star man Cristiano Ronaldo, has at his disposal a player nearly the equal of Barcelona’s Messi? CR7 scored three of Madrid’s five goals in their 5-3 aggregate quarter-final victory over Turkish side Galatasaray, and it’s hard to imagine Dortmund being able to keep him from notching during the semi-final. Then again, Madrid probably won’t be able to keep a clean sheet in the first leg in Dortmund – Madrid has only kept the opposition out once in 10 Champions League games this season – and if Dortmund does score an away goal in the second leg, it’s anyone’s guess as to the eventual winner. “I don’t think Madrid will be afraid because of what happened in the group stage,” Dortmund general manager Hans-Joachim Watzke said. “They will respect us, just like we respect them.”

Madrid, semi-finalists for a record 24th time, and in the final four for the third successive season, are bidding to win the competition for a record 10th time, with Mourniho hoping to become the first man to win three European Cup or Champions Leagues with three different clubs. Many neutrals would love to see Madrid make it to the final, if their biggest rivals Barcelona also get there. But soccer cares little for romance, and Dortmund and Munich will be hoping to put on “El Clasico” of their own.

Prediction: First leg Borussia Dortmund 2-1 Real Madrid. Second leg Real Madrid 2-1 Borussia Dortmund. Semi-final to be decided on penalties, which is nigh on impossible to call!

MORE: Can Cristiano Ronaldo Do a Maradona for Portugal?


This is a poor quality article, the prediction is even poorer. The author has absolute disrespect for the Bayern performance this year, and Messi is being regarded as a superhuman on the football field. He is definitely the best, but one must remember that an industrious defense could counter his skill with utmost dexterity. 

Bayern should win 3-1 at home, Barca should win 2-1 at Camo Nou. Bayern to play Real in the finals. 


I would suggest to the author of this article to see first some statistics before posting such ridiculous predictions. This year the words “FC Barcelona” and “clean sheet” are almost antonyms. Does he want me to remind him Barcelona’s record in their last 10 home games? Ok. The brilliant Barcelona defence managed to keep a clean sheet (at home) in 3 out of 10 occasions. And the two of them had been against Mallorca (who are at the bottom of La Liga) and Deportivo La Corunia (who are third from the bottom).

I am not saying that Barca will not go through. I am just saying that they will definitely concede against Bayern regardless of Messi playing or not. Also with or without Messi, it depends a lot and on how well Bayern will play too. Bayern on their day can beat Barca even with a top form Messi. My own prediction is Bayern-Barca 2-1 (or 3-1) and Barca-Bayern 2-1 (or 2-2). If the results are both 2-1 then the tie will be decided on penalties. I can see Bayern going through on penalties because of experience (despite painful memories) and much better goalkeeper. The fact that the return leg is in Camp Nou can actually be an advantage for Bayern if they go to penalties as they will not choke as they did in the home final last year.


I find it absolutely hilarious that you believe Bayern Munich with one of the most potent attacks in all of world football will come up scoreless in the second leg against Barca who have without question the worst defense left in the competition.  Tag onto that the fact that 3 out of Barca's back 4 are only one card away from suspension and starting defender Javier Mascherano is suspended for the first leg in Munich.  If Barca go through, it will be just barely and they most certainly won't be keeping Bayern's ridiculously potent attack off the scoresheet even at home.  PSG nearly eliminated Barca and scored 3 goals against them and Bayern is literally about 5 times better than PSG and 10 times better than AC MIlan


I cannot wait for that set of Bayern v Barca games.  I'm kind of shocked at the prediction even with Messi in the game.  Both teams are loaded on paper but Bayern has looked really sharp.

Hope Madrid loses.  Still fuming over that red on Nani.  Man U should be there.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 319 other followers